Monday, August 29, 2011

The Spirit of War - Chau Ta

The Vietnam War inflicted pain on many Vietnamese and American families. Over 300,000 people died during this tragic 20-year conflict. Despite the international treaties established during the Geneva Convention of 1949 against the inhumane treatment of prisoners of war and wartime civilians, the Vietnam War did not abide by these terms. There are many accounts regarding the torture of war captives that were beat with fists, clubs, and rifle butts. This brutality caused the death of many soldiers in prison. Although many bodies were identified after the end of the war, the bodies of hundreds of thousands of soldiers have not been accounted for and given the proper burial. In the Vietnamese culture, it is important to provide a proper burial for deceased family members in order to give the spirit peace. It is thought that wandering spirits that are not given the proper burial will stay to haunt the living. Therefore, Vietnamese culture is deeply rooted with superstitions that dictate the appropriate treatment of the body after death.

My father was a soldier of the Southern Vietnamese army and my mother was a high school student in Saigon during the war. Regardless of their role during this time, it is apparent that the war left permanent and ineradicable marks on my parents. My parents often retold many stories about the war as I was growing up; however, one story in particular embraced the ongoing impact of the war.

My mother recently told me about a friend that she had reconnected with though our social network at temple. This friend was married to one of the soldiers that never returned home from the war, which was very common for many families. As my mother retold the story, she noted the difficult times that her friend must have endured as a single mother after the war. The widowed friend had raised her child alone and never remarried.
Despite the child’s search efforts since the war, there had been no indication of her father’s survival. As such, a proper burial was never performed. His only “existence” came from her mother’s stories. Now an adult in her 30s, the child continued to stay close by her mother’s side. The mother had no other family; her only family was her child and her “husband.” Regardless of what others said and the speculation over the soldier’s death, the friend said that she never stopped seeing or speaking to her “husband.” To her, he was still alive. He had never left her side, but no one else could see or hear him. My mother remembered asking her friend to describe her husband, but the image that she portrayed was of the man that my mother remembered over 30 years ago. The husband had not aged and had not changed from the day he left for war; he remained dressed in uniform and was still optimistic about serving for his country.

My mother and others close to the family often witnessed the friend wandering around aimlessly. No one, even her child, understood what she was doing. The friend claimed that her husband and his whisperings were guiding her, telling her where to go and what to do. No one could pull her from this part of her life. He was “real” to her.

My mother also remembered asking the child about her encounters with her father. She never saw or heard from him like her mother did. The only images of her father came from old photographs and what she saw in her dreams. But he never looked the way that her mother described. He was always drenched in blood and screaming in pain. The child said that this dream never changed for her; it was a recurring nightmare. She could never feel the warm presence that her mother did.

Stories of soldiers that remained missing in action and the spirit that stayed were very common in the aftermath of the war. For many families, the search never ended and for some, the “soldier” never left. The Vietnam landscape remains covered with bodies awaiting the proper burial to give peace to these spirits.

22 comments:

  1. Your story was very well written and everything was very easy to believe. The way the information was presented kept me reading and held my attention. Good job!

    ReplyDelete
  2. You explaining the Vietnam culture really helps me believe the story. It is weird how the mom sees her husband in a young state but the daughter sees him in a horrible way. It makes me feel sad for the daughter. But I thought it was a good story.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I thoroughly loved reading your story and really enjoyed how you incorporated Vietnamese history. You're writing style is very captivating and detailed. This seemed very realistic which I also really liked.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I loved the story. It was very well written and raises a good argument. The ending wraps it up perfectly. The ways you went about describing this friend and her child make it so much more real, and there's certainly credibility from the history in the beginning.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Great job on the introduction paragraph. The background info was just right, just enough so i understood. The thesis statement was good too, a bit robotic though.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I loved this story! All the information that backed up your story made it credible as well as just being straight up interesting. You also are a great writer. This story was very believable. Good job!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Great story! Your background info is very detailed and your vivid writing paints a picture for the reader. I felt the emotion in your writing and you made me believe that this is all true. You also show a lot of credibility from your introduction and how you brought yourself into the story. Great job!

    ReplyDelete
  8. I really liked this story. Stories like this about war are common so it makes it even more believable. The facts helped the credibility also. Very well written.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Great story! letting the audience know about the Vietnamese culture was a great idea! The fact that the wife can see her husband in a good way and the daughter in a horrible way makes your story scary!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Nice story. To keep this short, in your analysis, I would argue that there was emotion that many can relate to. Losing someone close affects many in ways that they create a false reality to compensate for the lose/heartache. It actually could be called a psychological disorder. Perhaps a mild form of schizophrenia. So you can appeal to logic.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Not only is this the most clearly written story i have read so far, but also extreamly believeable. My favorite part of the whole story was the part where you fit into it! the personal family history from the war really grabbed me immediatly. Really quite an excellent piece of writing Chau, im impressed!

    ReplyDelete
  12. There is a lot of information contributing to the factuality of this story and i like to see that a lot. Its like you researched to write this, and if you didnt it just makes the story seem even more true in the end. This is one of the better ones that i read because it kept me informed and entertained the entire time.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Very good story. It was very well written, with lots of detail and no grammatical errors that i recognized. It was also very believable. If I had to say one thing that needed improvement the only thing I can think of is that it felt like i was reading a documentary rather than feeling as much intensity as possible, but that is even hard to say. Excellent job.

    ReplyDelete
  14. the background info and the explanation behind the Vietnamese culture makes this story very credible.i this story so much because i feel like besides informing us of what they have experienced you're also telling us how much this has changed their lives and that this emotional roller coaster still happens today

    ReplyDelete
  15. This story has a lot of details and historical fact about the culture that the Vietnamese have because of the Vietnam War. I like the facts that you use which add to the creditably of the story. The way that you and your family have connected to the story also adds to the creditability. It is well written because I don't see any grammar mistakes. Overall this is a great story that is believable to the reader

    ReplyDelete
  16. Great story! Very easily to believe, The first and last paragraph I believe gave the story most of your credibility. The historical facts, and how well you know about this stuff make even more believable. Nice work!

    ReplyDelete
  17. Your story was very well written and believable. It was very credible because of your 1rst and last paragraph. You had great detail. Overall this was a great story!

    ReplyDelete
  18. Great introduction. All the facts and history made me excited to hear what story you had to share. Explaining how this story related to you personally made it more interesting to read. It was a bit factual but very well written. Great job

    ReplyDelete
  19. Your story was very well written. I enjoyed it quite a lot. The facts in the beginning and tying it to your conclusion helped. It made the story come to life more. I loved your conclusion about soldiers waiting for a proper burial. The story seems credible, but I didn't understand how the story related to you.

    ReplyDelete
  20. I really loved this story. It definitely it believable, you add so much credibility with all the detail and fact you add in the introduction about the Vietnam war and all the soldiers that never returned. You use great vocabulary and all your sentences flow and transition very well. I wish you had expanded a little on the child and what the nightmares meant, I was curious to know a little more of what happened in that regard. Great story!

    ReplyDelete
  21. This story is very believable. All of the facts and details about the war and the Vietnamese culture really added to the credibility of the piece. The fact that your mother knew this lady makes it more believable. The emotional appeal to this piece makes the reader want to believe the story, to believe that a mourning single mother could still be comforted by her husband even if she seemed mad to the rest of the world. Your ending paragraph was very effective in explaining why this could happen, making the seemingly supernatural, plausible and understandable.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Your story was very well written and the thing seem credibility in your story.You use great vocabulary and all your sentences flow and transition very well

    ReplyDelete